How to find untapped creators like a brand's best performers

For agencies asked to find more creators like the ones that have already performed: how to build a lookalike list from public sponsorship history, and where it still needs a person.

By Muatasim BaigUpdated 5 min read

The short answer

Start with the brand's repeat creators, since a brand that kept paying someone has seen results it likes. Write down what they have in common: niche, size, format, language and audience. Then list the creators who have worked with the brand's direct competitors, keep the ones who match that profile, and remove anyone the brand has already worked with. What's left are creators who have taken sponsors in the category but haven't worked with your client.

Why start from the brand's own repeat creators

A client who asks for more creators like its best ones usually means the ones that converted. You won't see that data, but you can see who the brand kept paying. A repeat sponsorship is the brand's own verdict, made with numbers you don't have. How to find creators with repeat sponsorships covers how to read one, and how to tell a real run from a link left in a template.

Step 1: describe what the best creators share

List the brand's repeat creators and write down, for each one:

  • The niche, in narrower words than a category: privacy and security, PC hardware, Apple news.
  • The size, as a range of subscribers.
  • The format: long reviews, news, podcasts, short videos.
  • The language and the country the audience is in.
  • How the sponsor appears: a spoken read, a code, a link.

Then watch two or three videos from each. Look at who the content is for and how the read is done. This is the part no list does for you: audience fit comes from the videos, not from the numbers.

Step 2: list the creators who have worked with competitors

Name the brand's direct competitors, the ones a viewer would choose between. A creator who has worked with a competitor has shown two things: they take deals in the category, and their audience responds well enough that the competitor kept paying. List those creators the same way you listed the brand's own, with counts and dates.

Step 3: remove who has worked with the brand, then filter

  1. Take out every creator who has already appeared with your client's brand.
  2. Keep the ones that match the profile from step 1. Category labels are broad, so check the videos rather than trusting a label.
  3. Check the dates. A creator who promoted a competitor last week may be under an exclusive deal. One who stopped months ago may be free.
  4. Rank what's left by how long the competitor kept them. A creator a rival renewed for years is a stronger lead than a one-off.

A worked example

Take DeleteMe, a personal data removal service, and one of its direct competitors, Incogni. Kor counted these figures from public video descriptions, as of November 10, 2026, for creators it files under tech.

  • DeleteMe's long tech runs include Shannon Morse (74 videos, February 2021 to October 2026), Linus Tech Tips (62 videos since April 2023) and Simply Cyber (95 videos between June 2024 and February 2025). Security, privacy and tech news come up again and again.
  • Incogni had 531 tech creators. Of the 20 with the most Incogni videos, 18 had no DeleteMe video at all.
  • Some of those 18 are long Incogni relationships on general tech and internet channels: What about it!? (48 Incogni videos since June 2022), Undecided with Matt Ferrell (48 since May 2022) and AppleTrack (26 since September 2023). They are the first ones to watch.
  • Others show why step 1 matters. Two are German language tech channels, which only fit if the brand wants that market, and several are gaming channels that a broad tech label takes in.
  • All three of the longer runs had an Incogni video in the six weeks before that date, so ask about exclusivity before you pitch.

That's a shortlist of a few names out of hundreds, each with a reason to be on it and a known risk to check. What's left is watching the videos and asking about availability.

Where this method needs a person

  • Conversion. Repeat sponsorships stand in for performance; they don't measure it. Ask the brand which of its creators actually drove results.
  • Audience. Subscriber counts and labels don't tell you who watches. The videos and the comments do, and so does the creator's own audience data if they share it.
  • Exclusivity. A competitor's deal can close the category for a while. The dates tell you when to ask, not the answer.
  • Disclosure gaps. Some sponsorships leave no link or code in the description, and not every creator declares paid promotion (YouTube Help), so a competitor's list built from descriptions is never complete.
  • Brand fit. A creator who fits on paper can still be wrong for the brand's values or tone. That call is yours and the client's.

Questions

What is a lookalike creator?

A creator who shares the traits of a brand's best performers, such as the niche, the audience, the format and a track record with sponsors in the category, but who hasn't worked with the brand yet.

Should I pitch a creator who has worked with a competitor?

Often, yes, because it shows the category fits their audience. Check the dates and ask about exclusivity first, and never use deal terms a creator shared with you in confidence.

Can AI build a lookalike list for me?

It can do the listing and the removing quickly if it has sponsorship data to read, and Claude can rank the candidates against the profile you write. Watching the videos and judging the fit stay with you.

Sources

  1. YouTube Branded Content Policies, YouTube Help

Each source was opened and checked on November 10, 2026.